So you want a coach who understands that your faith isn’t an add-on- it’s woven into everything. Where do you even start? Search “Christian life coach” and you’ll get page after page of people who all sound pretty much the same, so how do you tell who’s actually a good fit for YOU?
Before you start interviewing coaches, it helps to know what you actually want help with. Not sure? Take the free Holistic Life Audit- it walks you through 25 areas of your life so you can see where you’re thriving and where you’re stuck.
First, a Quick Note About Me
I don’t call myself a Christian life coach. I’m a life coach who is Christian, and those values are part of how I work.
So take this as advice from someone who has hired coaches herself- and learned some of this the hard way.
What I Learned From Hiring My Own Coaches
I’ve had some pretty awful experiences with coaches. Some weren’t a great fit for me, but I was so desperate for direction that I worked with them anyway- people who had different ideas about how I should show up. From that, I learned that I need a coach who is going to let me show up as my authentic self, not one who wants me to present myself as something other than I am.
The coach I’m working with now is about as authentic as it gets. In all the work we do together, the ways he asks me to show up in the world align with who I am, who I want to be, my values and my faith- and that’s pretty huge. I also appreciate that he is no BS and doesn’t waste my time or his. He’s responsive to my feedback, he holds me to the line, and he holds me accountable.
All the things I want in a coach for myself are the things I bring to the table with the women I coach.
The Red Flag I Missed
Watch out for coaches who are overly grandiose and bragging. That was the mistake I made with my first coach. He bragged a lot about his phenomenal results, appeared to be very, very successful, and everyone seemed to want to be near him or be like him. All of that should have raised a red flag, and it didn’t- I saw what I wanted to see.
When I started to question his authenticity, his results and even the way he operated, I asked those questions in our group coaching forum. It turns out a lot of people felt the same way. He had gone out of his way to make everybody feel like his personal best friend in public, so nobody felt safe saying in the group what wasn’t working- they felt it would reflect on them, not on the coach.
The friendships I made through that group coaching program continue to this day. And just about all of us have run as fast as we can away from a guy who turned out to be a basic charlatan. That’s how that nightmare worked out. 🤦🏽♀️
So if a coach’s marketing is all about how amazing THEY are, pay attention to that- because a good coach should be a lot more interested in your life than in showing you how great theirs is.
Questions to Ask a Christian Life Coach
Whoever you talk to, ask these before you hire anyone (and yes, ask me too):
- How do you bring faith into coaching- and will you push it on me?
- What does a typical week with you look like?
- How do you hold clients accountable, and what happens if I don’t follow through?
- What does it cost, and what’s included?
- Who do you work best with, and who isn’t a fit?
- Can I read reviews from past clients?
- What do you do if I need a licensed counselor instead? (Here’s how a life coach and a therapist are different.)
Pay attention to HOW they answer, not just what they say. Do they listen to you, or do they turn every question into a sales pitch?
How Faith Shows Up When You Work With Me
When I coach, faith is part of the conversation if you want it to be- prayer, Scripture, and asking “What is God asking of you here?” What I won’t do: preach, push my faith, act as your pastor or counselor, or tell you what God is saying to you. Here’s more about how faith shows up in my coaching.
Want to know what clients say? Read my client stories.
Your Next Step
Want to ask me these questions yourself? Book a free 15-minute meet & greet- a short intro and a chance to ask me anything. Ready to go deeper? Book a consultation- it’s 90 minutes, $250, and credited toward SPARK or ICE if you move forward. (Here’s what happens in a coaching consultation.)
So- be honest with yourself. Are you looking for a coach who will help you become more of who you already are, or someone who will tell you who to be?
More questions about choosing a coach? Start here.
Not sure where to start? Take the free Holistic Life Audit.