At its core, a mentor is someone you look up to and maybe try to emulate. A coach is someone who intentionally guides you, supports you and helps you become who you’re trying to be. (Not sure what you need help with first? Take the free Holistic Life Audit.)
Mentor vs. Coach
People use these two words like they’re interchangeable. They’re not (though I’ll admit, the lines can get a little blurry).
Mentor ~ someone who has been where you want to go, and shares what they learned along the way.
A mentor’s wisdom comes from their own experience. They’ve walked the road ahead of you, and they can tell you where the potholes are. That’s incredibly valuable- but it also means their advice is shaped by THEIR path, THEIR choices and THEIR life.
Coach ~ someone who builds a game plan around YOU, then trains you and holds you accountable while you run it.
Think about a football coach. They absolutely hand players a playbook. But that playbook is built for THIS team- these players, their strengths, their weaknesses and the opponent in front of them. And the coach doesn’t just hand it over and walk away. They run drills, call plays from the sideline, watch the film and adjust the plan when something isn’t working.
I’ve had both, and I’m grateful for both.
When I started working with Jon Mitchell, P.A., on my health, he didn’t hand me his plan. He built one around my needs and abilities, and he changed it based on my feedback and challenges. (Like when we realized I had no core strength. 🤦🏽♀️) That’s coaching.
My point is this: a mentor tells you how they did it. A coach builds a playbook for how YOU will do it- and then makes sure you run it.
And an accountability partner is different again- usually a friend or peer who checks in with you while you both work toward similar goals. (I break that one down in Accountability Coach.)
Both have their place. The question is- which one do you need right now?
What Makes a GOOD Christian Mentor?
I believe a lot of people would love to be your mentor. Not all of them should be.
I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: consider your source. Whose advice you listen to matters- and when it comes to your faith, it matters even more.
So what should you look for?
People who point you to Jesus, not to themselves. Paul said it best: “Follow my example, as I follow the example of Christ” (1 Corinthians 11:1). A good Christian mentor isn’t trying to make you a copy of them. They’re trying to help you look more like Him.
They live what they teach. Anyone can quote Scripture. Watch how they treat their spouse, their kids, the server at the restaurant. (Yes, the server. That one tells you a LOT.)
They tell you the truth- for the right reasons. A good mentor will tell you things you don’t want to hear. But their motive is your growth, not their ego. Remember- motive matters.
They walk with you, not over you. “As iron sharpens iron, so one person sharpens another” (Proverbs 27:17). Sharpening goes both ways. A good mentor is humble enough to keep learning, too.
They’re pointing you forward. Paul told Timothy, “And the things you have heard me say in the presence of many witnesses entrust to reliable people who will also be qualified to teach others” (2 Timothy 2:2). From Paul to Timothy, then from Timothy to others, and so forth. A good mentor doesn’t want you to need them forever- they want you to grow so much that, someday, you’ll be the one mentoring someone else.
Where I Fit
I don’t call myself a Christian life coach. I’m a life coach who is Christian, and those values are part of how I work.
If you’re ready for someone to build a playbook around YOU- and then make sure you run it- that’s what SPARK, my six-week virtual coaching program ($2,500.00), is for. Start with a consultation.
Having considered all this, who is speaking into your faith right now? And are they pointing you to Jesus- or to themselves?
Not sure where to start? Take the free Holistic Life Audit.
You may also want to read: Spiritual Coach vs Christian Life Coach: What’s the Difference?